About a month ago the omnipresent Christian radio station KLOVE wrapped up its fundraising drive. You probably heard it, too. Pleas went out for more funding and you had kids giving their allowances, businesses committing, single moms pledging, families pledging, the works. God bless 'em if that's how the Lord is leading them to spend their money. The radio in my Volvo doesn't work anymore, one of the effects I suspect of a vehicle with 323,000+ miles on it, so I don't listen to KLOVE as much as I have in the past. I do spend more time in the Volvo praying, which is a good thing. KLOVE is about our only option out here in Gloucester, Va., as far as Christian radio, so we listen to it in the van. I'm really not sure where I stand on KLOVE ... I appreciate the effort to bring Christian music to the masses on a platform that literally stretches across the country. But I hear the same songs over and over again and many times I'm looking for something fresher and seem to hear songs I heard 10 years ago again and again. As I said to Ethan a week or so ago while we were riding in the van, "Is no one making any decent Christian music anymore?" That being said, I decided to take a peek at KLOVE's books as I did about a year and a half ago on this blog. Let's just say being one of the bigwigs at KLOVE pays off handsomely.
As I mentioned, KLOVE stretches across the country and has radio stations and transmitters all over the place, so it's a big business from that standpoint with lots of employees. The parent organization of KLOVE, Educational Media Foundation, reported revenues last year of $88.2 million, according to forms filed with the IRS. Total payroll, including benefits and taxes, topped $25 million and net revenue was $16.7 million, according to the forms filed with the IRS.
I'm sure you've all heard the voice of KLOVE President Mike Novak, especially at pledge time, and last year (2009) his total compensation was $506,198, according to documents filed with the IRS. Think about that for a minute ... wow, that's a ton of money. It takes 12,655 people pledging $40 a month just to cover his compensation. Is he operating Christian radio stations or working on Wall Street? He received $343,792 in base compensation (that's $28,649 per month) and "bonus & incentive" compensation of $110,000 (A lot of us got bonuses on par with that last year, right?), other reportable compensation of $9,628, retirement & deferred compensation of $22,549 and "nontaxable benefits" of $20,229. The big question to me is what is acceptable for a guy of Novak's position and stature? Is $506,198 acceptable, considering there's no disclaimer come pledge time that 12,655 of you monthly pledgers are just paying for Mike? As the guy who runs what essentially is a national organization, is he deserving of that paycheck?
Here's a couple of head-scratchers from the IRS forms. Dick Jenkins, the former president who is no longer with KLOVE, received $300,000 in "other reportable" compensation and another $13,196 in nontaxable benefits. That's only 7,830 $40-per-month pledgers to pay for a guy no listed as the "former president." Speaking of guys no longer with the organization ... former radio personality and programming director Jon Rivers left KLOVE in early 2009 and earned $261,543 in "other reportable" compensation and $3,659 in retirement and other deferred compensation last year, for a total of $265,202. Rivers subsequently attributed his departure to an addiction to prescription painkillers and maybe there was a contract or something that KLOVE couldn't get out of. Who knows. All told, KLOVE listed 14 people earning a minimum of $114,000 or more last year on its IRS forms. Not bad for Christian non-profit work.
Don't be fooled. "Christian ministry" often seems to be simply big business operating as a "non-profit." Sure there's plenty of good hearts out there at KLOVE with a desire to serve Jesus Christ and play Christian music and the like. But when and where does "Christian ministry" blur the line between personal gain? I think whether you are a pastor at a church, a CEO of a Christian "non-profit" organization, a missionary, or in whatever capacity you believe the Lord is calling you and leading you and directing you, when it comes to money the question always boils down to whether or not the Lord gives you a peace about your paycheck. Is there any check at all on your heart? When you read the Bible every morning (hopefully you're reading the Bible ...) are you paying attention to what is being said about money? How do you justify these paychecks? The Apostle Paul had something to say about this: "For the love of money is a root of all kinds of evil, for which some have strayed from the faith in their greediness, and pierced themselves through with many sorrows." (1 Tim. 6:10 NKJV) Jesus, the ultimate authority, weighed in on this: "Do not lay up for yourselves treasures on earth, where moth and rust destroy and where thieves break in and steal; but lay up for yourselves treasures in heaven, where neither moth nor rust destroys and where thieves do not break in and steal. For where your treasure is, there your heart will be also." (Matthew 6:19-21 NKJV)
WOW, thx for this info, I called Klove today @ getting sick n tired of their marketing ploys laced with guilt trips and they did not deny (I have a marketing background) the push pull marketing, east coast hard hitter and nearly in tears get their hearts. this is a well planned marketing strategy that employs every marketing facet outside of sex. ie repetition - hit em every few minutes. walk them to the phone stepxstep, much harder hitting marketing than 15 yrs ago when I donated $40 a month for a year and I only made $11p/hr to support a family of 4. 2 yrs ago when I called the Klove line to talk to a Pastor about my daughters issues, no return call. They assured me on the phone today, when I brought all this up, that the pastors return each n every call - NOT! I told her I don't trust their word based on that... and want to know their salaries, as I would not contribute donations to folks making more than me - she agreed. most of what she said was cold hearted canned responses not sincere. I also suggested they use actual Christian Business for commercials for a WIN-WIN-WIN so Christian Businesses can advertise honestly, and consumers and listeners know where to find Christian Businesses. I know why they don't - they would not make as much profit as they do with donations. This is criminal, corruption, greed and should be exposed. I make $42,500 a year, which I'm grateful for, and I'm not about to fund 14 folks making $114K and Mr. Novak. I'm appalled! U called it on Matthew 6:19-21!
ReplyDeleteI agree. I do not see where a person making half a million per year thinks its acceptable to ask the common hardworking soul for more. I am NOT judging; it just concerns me.
ReplyDeleteNo problems with Mike making what he makes. I'm sure none of the folks commenting could run KLOVE and probably have not checked the compensation for the American Cancer Society $800k +, Girl Scouts $800k +, United Way $1 mil, UNCF $700k +, Boys Scouts $900k +, City of Hope $1.4 mil + and many more. Maybe Jessica, Genie and Matt can run one of these organizations? Or better yet I guess you'd be happier if these organizations didn't exist. That would be a shame as they help millions and millions of people each year. Oh yeah don't forget about your local lottery that takes in hundreds of millions each year of "common" folk money. All I know is that these folks are doing "SOMETHING" (more than most) and making a difference in millions of lives. Good organizations doing great things.
ReplyDeleteDavid, you're nothing but a fool drinking the KLOVE Kool-Aid. KLOVE senior management are nothing more than pickpockets from the pulpit.
DeleteI think that a more helpful measure is what percentage of income goes to compensation? Michael Novak makes an uncommonly high amount given the overall expenses of his organization.
DeleteLet's take the American Cancer Society, which you mentioned. Their CEO makes around $800,000 on over %800,000,000 in operational expenses. .10% is a pretty typical non-profit salary. It holds true for NPR (an more complex radio broadcasting organization) and many of the ones you mentioned.
By contrast, Novak's salary is over $500,000 on operational expenses of 91,000,000, which is almost .6% of expenses. That's very high and doubly ponderous in a Christian organization.
This comment has been removed by the author.
ReplyDeleteThank you Mike for taking the time to do this homework. It is exactly what I needed to know before making a decision to support the latest fundraising drive. You efforts are definitely appreciated.
ReplyDeleteYou're welcome Jourdan. For the latest financial information on KLOVE, go here: http://14kids.blogspot.com/2014/08/a-big-year-for-klove-inside-their.html
ReplyDeleteTake care,
Matt
$500.000 a year. Wow you could store up a lot of treasures in this world. But that wouldn't get you in to heaven. It is easier for an elephant to thread through the eye of a needle, than for a rich man to get in to heaven. So keep telling yourself that $500.000 a year is justified for what he does. I think he could learn a thing or two about king Solomon.
ReplyDeleteI realize this post is old and so I have no idea who will see my comment, but I read this post earlier today and so many thoughts have run through my head to the point where I have to respond. 1) I think it's perfectly fine for us to know the incomes and financial doings of entities such as KLOVE. But I kind of feel it stops there. We do not work for that company for a reason. It is not our responsibility to handle anything at KLOVE. The only thing we are responsible for is praying how God wants us to use OUR hard earned money and pray for the ministry as a whole. 2) Yes, Mike Novak makes a ton of money, but who are we to say how much? We have no idea the depth of his job. It may involve 7 days a week or late nights or much time away from family. After all, he is in charge of a NATIONAL ministry!! He is one person in a group of people who have the amazing opportunity to bring thousands of people to Christ! We should be praising God that KLOVE exists and are doing everything they can to further the kingdom of God. 3) While we can all agree that Mike and maybe others at KLOVE make a lot of money, how dare we question that? For all we know, he and his family may donate $100,000 a year to run orphanages in Africa. He may live in a $150,000 ranch home he bought 20 yrs ago. He may be tithing 10% to his church. He may personally donate to 10 different local charities in his hometown or 10 different organizations around the world who help minister to the lost or provide resources to those in need. I could go on and on, but my point is, a lot of the money he is earning could be going right back into the kingdom of God because God has blessed him with much and he accepts that blessing humbly and with the understanding of the impact he can make. We do not know, but we can pray that he is open to God's direction. 4) We must remember that the people at KLOVE are human beings, imperfect and sinful, just like us. They make mistakes just like us. Until I have concrete evidence that KLOVE is hugely mishandeling the money I and many others give each month, I am going to praise God that I even have $40 to give each month and thank Him for leading me to give to KLOVE. Most people PRAY and receive CONFIRMATION that they are to give to this ministry. We are not forced to and God will not ask all of us. 5) My husband has 6 years post high school education and still only makes $41,000 as a high school special education teacher. I have my master's and stay home and homeschool our 2 children. Are things easy financially? Most of the time, no. Do I have a case for how "unfair" our scenario is? Sure. But boy what damage that would do!! I get bitter at times (imperfect human being), but I am almost in tears at this moment thinking of HOW MANY BLESSINGS my family has been given by God!! Do we deserve it? Heck no. I try my best to be thankful and grateful for all we have and for all we don't have. We try our best to be good stewards of the money we do have and we must remember, it's not ours anyway! It all belongs to God! 6) God never promised things would be "fair." Especially the kind of fair our selfish human minds think of. He is a GOOD GOD, but we will not all have high paying jobs nor will we be exempt from challenges or pain or hard times. He simply asks us to be RESPONSIBLE for what we do have, what we've been given and to do what He has asked us to do with our time, money, resources, influence, etc. As long as we compare ourselves to who others are and what they have, we will make excuses. Compare yourself to yourself and then progress can be made!! God bless!
ReplyDeleteStephanie you are so right! There is nothing else that needs to be said. For all we know Mr. Novak is giving a majority back to K-lov and living very modestly and with great generosity. Only the Lord knows the heart! God bless K-lov!
DeleteI have done some work for Mike. He lives quite modestly. You would not think he was rich by looking at his house or possessions. He is not two-faced at all. He was as kind to me at his home as he sounds on the radio. I am not a donor either. I am a nobody.
DeleteWhen KLOVE bought the Gloucester, VA station they paid 3 million for it, from another religious entity, and immediately asked for a main studio waiver so they could run it without employees.
ReplyDeleteThe sad part is many, many good people have lost their jobs because of the these sales to KLOVE. Recently WHMK in NC let go it's entire local staff, only to be replaced with a KLOVE satellite dish and a small computer. She the KLOVE waiver request here:
https://licensing.fcc.gov/cdbs/CDBS_Attachment/getattachment.jsp?appn=101653341&qnum=5170©num=1&exhcnum=3
The former staff of WMHK has a 'support' page https://www.facebook.com/rememberingwmhk/
So my suggestion is to support your LOCAL Christian station, instead of these national groups that don't give back to their local communities.
Happened in Omaha. Not a sale to KLOVE, but them moving into Omaha, begging for donors to support it so people could hear the Gospel. But there was already a Christian station here. Why not take your mini$try to places where there legitimately isn't any other Christian radio available? RIP 100.7 The Fish.
DeleteIt's funny, I looked this up with the purpose of finding out how much money he makes. I hope you all know how much more he can make #1, and #2, no one knows how much money he actually donates. I mean, 22 million in revenues, and the guy takes home 500,000. 10% of 22 million is 2.2 million. He is taking 1/4 of that. So of the total revenue the company makes he is taking 2.5%. Hmmmmm I wonder if that is fair or not?
ReplyDeleteGiving is a hard thing for us humans. We get so mixed up in our hearts & minds about it. I know I have.
ReplyDeleteLast year I struggled so much with all the perfectly able-bodied young men in our area that were begging for money from me in the Walmart parking lot. I spent a lot of time in prayer about it because I was so conflicted about it.
Finally God spoke to me one evening & I am so thankful! He reminded me what His purposes were for giving. It's for me, my heart & soul, that God calls me to give. And then He reminds me He loves a cheerful giver.
So I made the following commitment to Him: "I will not be stingy with money. It is not what is done with the money I give that matters. It is that I give it (not considering it more important than people), & the heart with which I give it (not judging the recipient but giving thanks to God that I have it to give). This is what You are focused on."
Kind of interesting that since I made that commitment to God, I haven't had even one of those young men come begging for money. Just confirms to me that the whole giving things is about my heart & my attitude, & has little to do with who gets it.
I want my heart clear before God! So I want to be a cheerful giver wherever He wants me to give, regardless of anything else! So help me, God!
Bad math... really bad math.
ReplyDelete"It takes 12,655 people pledging $40 a month just to cover his compensation." If he were making $506,000 PER MONTH, yes. But if a donor pledges $40/mo, that's $480/year, so contributions from 1,054 people pay Novak's salary.
I have lots of friends that call to talk tiki a preacher. They never called back and were cold. I will rather donate to my local station
ReplyDeleteI'll finish reading through the comments soon.
ReplyDeleteIt's now October 2019, and I just pledged $30 a month. I know that Klove has helped me with some of their songs. I also know that your Tithes are between you and God. What the church or ministry does with your Tithes is between them and God. Yes, they pull some marketing tricks to get the money, but that's business. All the products in your homes is there as a result of Marketing. Some of these folks could have positions at companies paying WAY more, but are here instead.
Let God judge those whome are nefarious. Do not cast judgement yourselves.
Well said. We can only do as God leads us to do. What gives us the right to question what he does with what God has given him, would we want the same done to us? What about the celebrities and sports players, no one seemingly cares so much where God leads them to spend their monies. All any of us can do is what we feel God leading us to do with pure, sincere hearts. God Bless all!
ReplyDelete